Nintendo trip up in their own World?

Notes from the Mushroom Kingdom

With the 3DS launch now approaching rapidly, and anticipation reaching it’s highest point yet, Nintendo are finally beginning to divulge the big secrets of their new system. Next week will be Europe and America’s time to shine, as Nintendo unveil the release date, price and software line-ups for those two territories, but last weekend was all about Japan, and the first real demonstration of what the 3DS is capable of. But was Nintendo World 2011 a success? Well, yes and no.

Strictly speaking, the event itself went without a problem and finally gave us a look at what the 3DS has in it’s arsenal for the coming year. From Ocarina of Time to Paper Mario to Mario Kart to Metal Gear Solid, the big guns were out in force at this event, and by all accounts, were all just as enjoyable as expected. But the big stories from Japan are concerning the 3DS itself and how it’s coping with being such a powerful little handheld.

With the graphical prowess of the system not completely pushed to the limit yet, it’s hard to say how powerful the 3DS is. However, from Metal Gear and Resident Evil we can see that it has a much more advanced graphics unit than the original DS, and is probably on par with the Gamecube, and quite possibly the Wii. This power is split in half due to the 3D, but still, it’s an impressive feat. The problem though, and the biggest one to emerge from Nintendo World, is the battery life. Whereas the DS and DSi seemed to just go on forever, the 3DS only sports a 3-5 hour battery life while playing games. For a handheld, this is borderline abysmal. True, most users won’t play it for more than 3 hours at a time, and by turning the 3D and brightness down battery life can be saved, but for businessmen who are gamers and want a 3DS for a long flight, they’re going to be reaching for their charger before they’ve even left the airport.

We always knew the 3D would come at a price, but the battery cost is for me, too high. A 7 hour figure would have been better, but 3 hours just doesn’t cut it on a handheld. True, the results are great for those few hours it works, but despite Nintendo’s best efforts, it’s really not good enough. This could prove to be a major sticking point come launch as word gets out that the battery is done after one session.

In terms of the rest of the hardware, all seems well, so rest assured that the 3DS is a functional and well-built device. A niggle that IGN spotted with Kid Icarus was that the control scheme required analog nub movement and L-trigger firing, which, as you can imagine, is somewhat uncomfortable and unintuitive. While not a hardware problem, this is a sign of problems that could arise with some games in the future.

Nintendo also took the opportunity to show off their line-up for the Japanese launch, and I must say, I’ve never been so underwhelmed in my life. Now before I start here, let me clarify that this is the Japanese line-up, and if tradition holds true, everyone else will get a different line-up to this (Professor Layton for example would not make chronological sense if launched elsewhere for example). Nintendo’s only offering on Day 1 in Japan is Nintendogs + Cats, and elsewhere the line-up includes a new Layton game and Super Street Fighter IV (which looks to be a StreetPass flagship game) which leaves a very lacklustre line-up. The line-up also sets a dangerous precedent for the 3DS – many saw it as a console that would bring back the true gamers games to the system, but instead we’re seeing almost exclusively ‘casual’ games at launch.

While this will change in other territories, it’s worrying that at this stage, these are the only games Nintendo are ready to release. This would suggest to me that development time on the new system is much longer than expected, which is a worrying sign. Rumours persist that Ocarina 3D will be ready for the other launches, so it’s not all doom and gloom.

Finally we get to the big one – online. With SpotPass setting up the 3DS to potentially be continually online, many Nintendo fans, myself included, were looking for a much more robust online system. Videos of the Home menu though do show a rearrangement, but also an almost complete absence of any shop integration, user accounts, friends lists or accolade system. There is a log that records gameplay time which may turn out to be one or many of these things, but it strikes me that Nintendo appear to have dodged online once again in favour of keeping everything crammed into channels. I really hope that I’m proved wrong here, but from what I’ve seen, it looks like the Home menu is just DSi v1.1.

So as Nintendo World draws to a close, what do we make of the 3DS? Prior to the event, I literally couldn’t wait, and still, every time I see game footage my reaction is simply ‘wow’. But it’s the other information that trickled from the event that worries me. Nintendo’s stubborn refusal to implement online features; a lack of top quality launch titles; a battery that wouldn’t be acceptable on any modern day device and some big questions still left unanswered.

I’m convinced that as soon as I get my hands on one I’ll fall in love with it like the DS and Wii before it, but as each day passes and as each news item is presented to me, my pessimism grows. There’s no doubt this will be a success, but the level of success could be determined by what the 3DS has on it’s own, with no games in the system. The 3DS needs to be able to stand alone, and while 3D films could do that for it, the battery life is always going to come back to haunt it. Expect a 3DS Lite with a huge battery in 2012. It’s the natural thing to do surely?

6 replies »

  1. Hello you make a good point, and I also am sad about the Battery ;___; but I guess the power was too much, and after the pictures of the stolen Nintendo 3DS. I can see why Nintendo could not add a 2nd circle-pad, it just does not fit. I wish that the Nintendo 3DS had a easy open back cover for the Battery that way you can just bring along 3 extra ones. But i have yest the see the back of the System and i dont believe Nintendo will do so as they did long ago with the Gameboy.

    I find it funny that the Online mode is still on the downlow. Maybe There will be no push for Online like befor which would kind of suck a little, not that I mind, I mean when i play online its with random people and i dont care to make them my friend. I mostly play lan with others on my Nintendo DS-lite-i-LL system.

    About the launch titles in japan, It really did scare the s*** out of me. I would hate to only have Nintendogs+cats as my only Nintendo game. That would break my heart, Hopefuly Zelda OOT will make it in time and stuff, it looks ready but hell we might never find out.

    I hope that on Jan 19th Nintendo drops the bomb and blows everyone away. 199.99 price point 29.99 to 39.99 game price point. Zelda OOT, Street Fighter IV 3D edition, Ridge Racer, Random ubisoft/EA games.

  2. I pretty much agree with all of your points (except one: battery). Japan’s launch lineup has me worried. While Nintendogs + Cats may be enough for Nintendo there, it doesn’t entice me to drop $200-$300. It’s really troubling that they show Kid Icarus 3DS, etc. at E3, but none of those titles are even ready. So while the 3DS has a lot going for it from spring through summer, it seems best just to wait. I’m worried they are going to keep friend codes as well.. leaving any hope of a universal friends list on the cutting room floor. For years, so many fans argued Nintendo couldn’t rid DS/Wii of FCs midway through the lifespan.. that the change would have to be made when Nintendo started anew. Well, now is that time, and it seems like they ignored our requests. On top of that, what does 3DS have going for it now besides the 3D? It was touted as NOT a new generation of the DS, but a completely new system.. the next big thing. It sure doesn’t seem that way. As for the one point I disagreed on: battery life. DS Lite supposedly only lasts 5-8 hours according to Nintendo.. I think they underestimate to play it safe. Also, I rarely play portable games while out and about (weird, I know) so it isn’t as big an issue to me. I charge my Android device while it’s not in use, so I don’t see how 3DS would be any different. Only problem is there aren’t many games that would drain my battery to begin with. 😛

  3. While I do agree that the luanch line-up of japan isn’t that great, I also realize thats the Japan line-up the us and europe line-ups could be totaly different. As for the battery It was stated by nintendo that the DSi would be the same thing 3 – 4 hours, However not only was that a little underestimated its also the bettery life on its highest settings. Who knows? turn the 3D slider down a quarter way and the light settings down 3 clicks, we may just get 10 hours of battery life. Finnaly friend codes haven’t really been comfirmed, since Nintendo kept talking about how much they improved it they may just come out on the 19th and say that the 3DS does use friend codes.

  4. Why is everyone crying so much about the battery life? Just do what I do with my DS and PSP; Play with it pluged in! If you’re at home and not going to be gettting up from your seat for awhile, play plugged in.

    • Because the battery life, especially if it really is that limited, could be a huge problem for some people. People like Gaz, who have very long commutes, could run into battery life issues.

      Keeping it plugged in while you’re at home is one thing, but there aren’t outlets readily available on trains or airplanes or buses. I think this might be an exaggeration by Nintendo and the battery life will end up being longer, but if it turns out to only be around the three hour mark that’s unacceptable.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s